Kristol is still optimistic that somehow Egypt can turn into a democracy if the people can summon another 2011 revolution or make it to another election. Krauthammer on the other hand says hope in democracy in the first place was hopelessly romantic and now that Morsi is performing a coup d’etat, that once he becomes a dictator he won’t relinquish it. Kristol seems to think that’s a little too fatalistic for his tastes but Krauthammer argues that history is on his side.

Watch:




Comment Policy: Please read our new comment policy before making a comment. In short, please be respectful of others and do not engage in personal attacks. Otherwise we will revoke your comment privileges.

91 comments
PJRodman
PJRodman

I highly recommend The Restoration Weekend videos on David Horowitz TV. There are quite a few really good panelists and experts on the Middle East and the message is sobering for sure. We are remaining clueless it seems. CK is right. You could let them have their own nation and the violence would just continue. (All of the discussion is really good, but in response to the topic I talk about those videos...they begin on the second or third page...well worth a rainy day)

Alex
Alex

You can't undo 1000 years of cultural history. The Arab Spring and "democracy in the Middle East" that the Obamabots and the neocons talk about is a load of crock.

It's a horrible reason to go to war. Ghaddafi and Mubarak, say what we want about them, kept their region from becoming an Islamic theocracy.

Alex
Alex

Kristol has no credibility. This grinning snake was never a conservative.

Orangeone
Orangeone

How much kool-aid has Kristol been drinking recently?

Alex
Alex

He's been like that for a long time.

Rshill7
Rshill7

Ok, I'll take a whack at that.

1. Enough to have his name legally changed to Sweetie?

2. Enough to force him into a red dye#2/sugar coma?

3. Enough to make every kid from the 70's shout, "Hey Kool-aid Man"?

4. Enough to cover every square inch of his skin with condensation?

5. Enough to where I look upon him with condescension?

:-)

Orangeone
Orangeone

ROTFLMBO and I cannot stop!  Are you Twitter by any chance? If not, you might think of joining us.

Hey AmericanBorninCanada, Wolfie, Kong, PDXLady we could do a hashtag on this one, #KristolKoolaidImpacts

Orangeone
Orangeone

Back on the floor....laughing

Rshill7
Rshill7

Nope, In my day day all tweets were avian. Still are :-)

Speaking of avian. I grew up in Myrtle Beach and we (me and my little brother) put a bunch of bread crumbs out in the street one fine Sping day, all around one which was on a hook attached to some line which I was holding. A seagull swooped down and grabbed some, then several started swooping and grabbing. One got the piece attached to the hook and I had a kite! True story.

We finally got him free and he flew off. We never did that again.

Aine
Aine

I'm curious to know when Bill Kristol began using recreational drugs, because his capacity for reasoning seems to have dropped to nil. Who can forget the wrath and abuse he heaped upon Glenn Beck when Beck dared to suggest the reforming of the Caliphate?

BTW, State Department spokesman Mark Toner seems to have thrown King Abdullah of Jordan under the bus in recent days. This will be bad for him, imho, and for Israel. Abdullah is western-educated and seems a moderate man. He's doomed now that DOS has given him the Mubarak treatment.

mder4thegov
mder4thegov

Kristol's gone.

Conservator1
Conservator1

Bill Kristol was gone along time ago. He's now voicing opinions that he held for many years like raising taxes on the so-called rich - people earning $250,000 a year in the New York metropolitan area live like middle class Americans. Kristol just kept his mouth shut long enough to make millions selling the Weekly Standard.

PVG
PVG

Morsi and BO have a lot in common.......narcissists.

Jake Bourgeois
Jake Bourgeois

probably not the smartest move 2 make when the US is trying 2 figure out what 2 do about its budget...seems like a pretty easy couple billion 2 me

mikeinidaho
mikeinidaho

Kristol is an idiot. He has officially signed on to the Left's BS Brigade. He used to be a Conservative, but his quest to be included in all the right circles in DC has left him toting Obama and Comapany's water 24/7. He's the same traitor that said that We the People wouldn't mind if the Left raised rich people's taxes

anneinarkansas
anneinarkansas

Something or someone has gotten to Kristol. I can remember actually liking the man.

Krauthammer is smarter than all of them combined.

Kristol's opinions were with the WaPo man (???).

Rshill7
Rshill7

Isn't Kristol such a wonderful moderate? Oh boy, what is better than lukewarm? Wouldn't you love to have a piping hot grilled cheese sandwich and a bowl of tomato soup with oyster crackers sprinkled atop it? Yes please.

Wait a second, let it age for a several minutes till the temperature drops by 30-40 degrees. Yummy. That way the cheese can re-congeal and the tomato soup can develop that wonderful skin on the surface that comes off all in one slimy piece onto your spoon like partially dehydrated pus.

A greasy rubber sandwich and a tepid bowl of skin. Oooh wee, how good is that?

Billy: "I know your works, that you are neither cold nor hot: I would that you were cold or hot. So then because you are lukewarm, and neither cold nor hot, I will spew you out of my mouth." (Revelation 3:15-16 KJV)

In other words, you're disgusting. Now git.

But first, take this stack of Weekly Standard I got last year for Christmas and "kindle" a "fire" with them, OK? I haven't read a single full article from any of them. Maybe that'll heat you up a bit. If I wanted to read an obituary, I know right where to go in my local paper. You are full of dead man's bones yourself.

Constance
Constance

As I read your second paragraph, I was taking a bite of my morning toast. I am in awe of your description; however, when the butter on the toast hit my tongue, I was at the partially dehydrated pus section.

Full body shiver ensued. :)

Rshill7
Rshill7

:-) Ooops.

Alex
Alex

That's good.

Rshill7
Rshill7

"Hey Rs. Check this out!"

Okeedokie.

"What do you call a petite fortune teller who's just escaped from prison?"

I don't know, tell me.

"A small medium at large."

That's funny.

"I know, right?"

Right :-D

Conniption Fitz
Conniption Fitz

The problem with Egypt is Islam, the religion of hate, cruelty, lies, racism, barbarism, misogyny, slavery, malevolence, conquest, constant conflict, aggression, vengeance... death.

ryanomaniac
ryanomaniac

Krauthammer is absolutely correct. Has Kristol read any history or has he had his head in the sand while editing The Weekly Standard? Kristol is a weak stick if I've ever seen one.

RefudiateGOPe
RefudiateGOPe

"Is it going to be the Muslim Brotherhood? We should not stand for that, or with that, or by that. Any radical Islamists. No, that is not who we should be supporting and standing by ... we need to find out who was behind all of the turmoil and the revolt and the protests so that good decisions can be made in terms of who we will stand by and support."

"Nobody yet has explained to the American people what they know, and surely they know more than the rest of us know, who it is who will be taking the place of Mubarak and I'm not real enthused about what it is that, that's being done on a national level and from D.C. in regards to understanding all the situation there in Egypt.

"And in these areas that are so volatile right now because obviously it's not just Egypt but the other countries too where we are seeing uprisings, we know that now more than ever, we need strength and sound mind there in the White House."

-Sarah Palin, February 4, 2012

Conniption Fitz
Conniption Fitz

Sarah Palin is the refreshing, restoring antidote to our Muslim Bro-hood/Islam/homosexuality/gay-marriage/abortion loving/promoting so-called POTUS.

BikerHoop
BikerHoop

Let's see... Morsi has just essentially declared himself Supreme Commander. Everything he says is law and can't be questioned. Yeah, Bill, he's gonna give that up. It's the same kind of temporary a new temporary tax is.

Orangeone
Orangeone

And Bill thinks O is a great leader too. Makes me want to toss my cookies....

Rocco11
Rocco11

The Weekly Standard should merge with The Nation at this point, Kristol morphed into David Frum over a year ago.

Jay
Jay

Kristol represents everything that is wrong with the establishment Republicans these days.

CPAguy
CPAguy

Umm...democracies don't promote individual rights.

That is why democracy has largely failed in the middle east. They don't understand the individual freedom part...only the part that if they get enough votes they get their way.

Conniption Fitz
Conniption Fitz

The US is a Republic, with laws that (once) protected human life and rights, freedom of religion, free speech, property, etc. We now have laws that encroach on rights and destroy life, enable us to break all of GOD's higher law, the Ten Commandments and some that would force us to do so. Obama is systematically and intentionally destroying law and order, freedom and rights of religious conscience. He and his communist handlers are the enemy of US Constitutional law, human rights and freedom.

Dr. Frank Lippenheimer
Dr. Frank Lippenheimer

Kristol's been in the Bubble too long. He needs to take a burro ride to the bottom of Grand Canyon and then climb his way out on his own two feet. Maybe that would be enough to sweat the Beltway out of his system. *Or* maybe this is who he really is and always has been.

deTocqueville1
deTocqueville1

Who cares what Bill says. he is an intellectual lightweight living off of the capital of his father Irving. Dr. K is not much better usually pontificating with 20-20 hindsight. We should be listening to people like Palin and DeMint who expressed scepticism from the beginning about deposing Mubarak and intervening in Libya. And yes Bush and the neocons are naive believing we can change a thousand years of cultural history by force of arms and a kind and gentle occupation.

badbadlibs
badbadlibs

The left are pawns. satan has them in the palm of his sickening hand, doing his bidding, hastening the return of the ONLY TRUE POTENTATE. (1Tim. 6:15)

shield1
shield1

Islam is a theocracy. If our voted representatives actually did their homework, they would know that and adjust their policies accordingly. But... they're too consumed with PC to notice reality.

kong1967
kong1967

I believe Krauthammer is right and it's what I've been saying was going to happen all along....as soon as the Muslim Brotherhood put up a candidate after they said they wouldn't. I believe this is exactly what Obama wants, because he believes that America has too much power and the muslims don't have enough. Very easy to dupe the ignorant left who believed democracy was the end result, and still incredibly believe it.

Constance
Constance

Didn't Kristol support the so-called Arab Spring? Wasn't he one of the voices out there telling the rest of us loons on the right to calm down and get off the Muslim Brotherhood bandwagon? I do believe I am correct, but let me know. If I am correct, then his opinion on this matter is null and void. I may not always agree with Krauthammer's take on things, but he is usually pretty good on foreign issues like this. He wasn't one of those supporting that Spring thing too, was he? I don't remember. Geez, I hope not.

Patriot077
Patriot077

You are spot on, Constance. He is completely out of touch with reality with respect to the MB and Islam in general. I don't recall what CK may have said at the time, but I distinctly remember Kristol saying Beck was nuts when he said it was the start of the caliphate.

Constance
Constance

Thanks for confirming that for me. I knew my memory wasn't that off!

JeffWRidge
JeffWRidge

Krauthammer is right. Historically speaking, revolutions have mostly been corrupted. Some power hungry people are always sitting in the background pulling strings and manipulating naive people into surrendering their revolution to new dictators. By the time they realize that they have been conned, it's too late and the tyrants have consolidated power.

Libertyship46
Libertyship46

Obama, Clinton, and the other people in that administration who got us into this mess really believed that all they had to do was click their heals and wish democracy onto Egypt and it would be so. Never mind that the country never had either a history or an inclination for democracy as long as Egypt has been around for the past, oh, 3,000 years. Never mind that the Muslim Brotherhood, the organization that killed Sadat and spawned literally thousands of terrorists and Islamic radicals, was poised to take over the country. And never mind that the man currently running Egypt not only hates Israel and the United States, but actually wanted to set up a commission trying to prove that 9/11/2001 was a fake. Never mind all of that. Obama and Clinton were just certain that democracy would magically take over in Egypt as soon as Mubarak was thrown under the bus.

So I guess they were wrong. We are trying to force democracy onto countries that never had it, never wanted it, and have absolutely no history in trying to achieve it. Egypt, Iraq, Libya, Algeria, Tunisia, all of them are now falling back to dictators, only now these dictators are very anti-American, anti-Israel, anti-west, and want to embrace a legal system that has Sharia Law as its foundation. And who only knows what the collapse of Syria and soon Jordan will bring. Good going, Obama and Clinton. You broke the Middle East, now you try and fix it. Good luck with that. Now the world is stuck with your mistakes.

StrangernFiction
StrangernFiction

Hussein has gotten exactly what he wanted.

Constance
Constance

With a heavy heart, I agree with you on that.

sjmom
sjmom

Gotta agree with Charles on this one, except his "if the administration had". What he should have said is if the Obama administration was not complicit in this with the Muslim Brotherhood they would have...................

Vorlath
Vorlath

They won't trust Democracy anymore either. That's something the Brotherhood wants to achieve as well.

JacksonPearson
JacksonPearson

A nation can't go forward with Islam/Sharia law forced upon them...

Egyptians are going to learn a very harsh lesson, that wherever Islam spreads, freedom dies.

Rshill7
Rshill7

Right. Islam is the most concentrated evil on the planet.

StrangernFiction
StrangernFiction

If Egypt is headed towards democracy they are headed in a different direction then the USA.